Breville Barista Express Impress vs Breville Barista Pro

Breville Barista Express Impress vs Breville Barista Pro

If you’re in the market for a high-quality espresso machine, chances are you’ve come across Breville’s offerings. The Breville Barista Express Impress and the Breville Barista Pro are two of the most popular mid-range home espresso machines. They both promise café-quality espresso, built-in grinders, and user-friendly features that make them appealing to beginners and experienced baristas alike.

But which one is right for you? In this in-depth comparison, I’ll cover everything you need to know, from design and ease of use to espresso quality, steaming power, and overall value. Having spent time using both machines, I’ll share my hands-on experience to help you make the best decision.

Table of Contents

Breville Barista Express Impress vs Breville Barista Pro Comparison Chart

If you click the links below, under the product images, you will be redirected to Amazon.com. In case you then decide to buy anything, Amazon.com will pay me a commission. This doesn’t affect the honesty of this review in any way though.

FeatureBreville Barista Express ImpressBreville Barista Pro
Breville Barista Express ImpressBreville BES878 Barista Pro
Check the best price on AmazonCheck the best price on Amazon
Machine TypeSemi-automaticSemi-automatic
Heating SystemThermocoilThermoJet
Heat-Up Time~30 seconds~3 seconds
Grinder TypeIntegrated conical burr grinderIntegrated conical burr grinder
Grind Settings25 settings30 settings
Tamping SystemAssisted tamping (Impress Puck System)Manual tamping
Pre-InfusionYesYes
Pressure Control9-bar extraction9-bar extraction
User InterfaceButtons + analog pressure gaugeLCD screen with digital controls
Shot Volume ControlSingle & double-shot presetsSingle & double-shot presets
Steam WandManual, less powerfulManual, more powerful
Milk Frothing SpeedSlowerFaster
Milk Froth QualityGoodExcellent (better microfoam)
Hot Water DispenserYesYes
Water Tank Capacity2L (67 oz)2L (67 oz)
Drip Tray SizeLarger (requires less frequent emptying)Smaller
Descaling ReminderYesYes (via LCD screen)
Cleaning AlertsYes (automated reminders)Yes (via LCD screen)
Dimensions (W x D x H)33 x 38 x 41 cm35.4 x 41 x 40.6 cm
Weight12.9 kg (28.4 lbs)9.1 kg (20.1 lbs)
Construction MaterialStainless steelStainless steel
Color OptionsBrushed stainless steelMultiple (stainless steel, black, white, etc.)
Best ForBeginners, ease of useIntermediate to advanced users, customization
My individual reviewsBreville Barista Express Impress reviewBreville Barista Pro review

Key Takeaways from the Comparison Table:

  • Barista Express Impress is better for beginners due to assisted tamping, automatic dosing adjustments, and simpler controls.
  • Barista Pro is faster, more powerful, and better for advanced users, with a superior steam wand, a digital LCD interface, and finer grind control.
  • Both machines have the same water tank capacity (2L) and pressure control (9-bar extraction), but differ in workflow speed and user control.

If you want more automation and consistency, the Barista Express Impress is the better choice. If you value speed, precision, and a professional-style experience, the Barista Pro is worth the extra investment.

Overview of Both Machines

Breville has built a reputation for producing high-quality, user-friendly espresso machines, and both the Barista Express Impress and Barista Pro are standout models in their lineup. While they share many features, they also have distinct differences that cater to different types of users.

The Barista Express Impress is an upgraded version of the original Barista Express, designed with additional features to make espresso-making easier and more consistent, particularly for beginners. It incorporates an assisted tamping system, which helps ensure uniform puck preparation. This added automation means you don’t have to worry as much about getting the perfect tamp pressure—an essential factor in pulling high-quality espresso shots.

The Barista Pro, on the other hand, is a more advanced machine with an emphasis on speed and precision. It does not include assisted tamping, meaning users have complete control over their puck preparation. However, it compensates for this with faster heat-up times, a more intuitive LCD display, and a more powerful steam wand. These features make the Barista Pro better suited for intermediate and advanced users who want more manual control over their espresso process.

Let’s break down the core similarities and differences between these two espresso machines.

1. Built-In Grinder

Both machines come with a built-in conical burr grinder, which is a major convenience. Instead of needing a separate grinder, you can grind your coffee beans directly into the portafilter, ensuring optimal freshness.

  • The Barista Express Impress features 25 grind settings, which is sufficient for most espresso brewing needs. It also has an automatic dosing system that determines the correct amount of coffee based on your previous shot, making it easier for beginners.
  • The Barista Pro has a slightly improved grinder with 30 grind settings, providing finer control over grind size. While this may not be noticeable for casual users, those who enjoy experimenting with different beans and extraction styles will appreciate the added flexibility.

2. Tamping System: Manual vs. Assisted

One of the biggest differences between these two machines is how they handle tamping.

  • The Barista Express Impress introduces Breville’s “Impress Puck System”, which automatically tamps your coffee grounds with the correct pressure. This feature ensures more consistent extractions and eliminates one of the most common beginner mistakes: uneven or incorrect tamping.
  • The Barista Pro requires manual tamping, just like a traditional espresso machine. This provides greater control over puck preparation, but it also introduces more room for error. Users need to practice their tamping technique to achieve consistent results.

3. Heating System and Heat-Up Time

Heating time is another crucial factor when comparing these two machines.

  • The Barista Express Impress uses a Thermocoil heating system, which takes about 30 seconds to fully heat up. This is reasonable, but not the fastest in Breville’s lineup.
  • The Barista Pro is equipped with Breville’s ThermoJet heating system, which heats up in just 3 seconds. This means you can pull your first shot almost immediately after turning the machine on, making it ideal for busy mornings when you need coffee quickly.

4. Interface and User Experience

The way you interact with each machine also differs.

  • The Barista Express Impress maintains a more traditional espresso machine layout, with physical buttons and an analog pressure gauge. This gives it a classic feel, but it lacks some of the modern conveniences of a digital interface.
  • The Barista Pro has a sleek LCD screen, which provides useful real-time information such as grind size, extraction time, and shot volume. This makes it easier to fine-tune your espresso shots and troubleshoot any issues.

5. Who Are These Machines For?

  • Barista Express Impress: Designed for beginners or those who prefer a more guided experience. The assisted tamping system reduces the learning curve and improves consistency, making it a great choice for users who want café-quality espresso without spending months perfecting their technique.
  • Barista Pro: Aimed at users who want more manual control and don’t mind a slightly steeper learning curve. The faster heat-up time, improved steam wand, and digital interface make it ideal for those who want to refine their barista skills over time.

In summary, both the Barista Express Impress and Barista Pro are excellent machines, but they cater to different audiences. The Impress model is better suited for those who want consistency and ease of use, while the Pro is ideal for those who value speed, control, and customization.

Design & Build Quality

When investing in a home espresso machine, design and build quality play a significant role in the overall user experience. A well-designed machine should not only look good on your countertop but also be intuitive, durable, and efficient in terms of workflow. Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro are well-constructed and thoughtfully designed, but they cater to slightly different preferences.

In this section, we’ll dive deep into their aesthetic appeal, size and footprint, material quality, control layout, and ergonomics to help you understand which machine suits your needs best.

Aesthetic Appeal: Classic vs. Modern

Both machines share a brushed stainless steel finish, giving them a sleek and professional look. However, their overall designs have some key differences that might influence your decision based on personal preference.

Barista Express Impress: A Classic Espresso Machine Look

The Barista Express Impress follows the classic espresso machine aesthetic, with a traditional layout that includes an analog pressure gauge, physical buttons, and a portafilter-friendly design. This model maintains much of the look of the original Barista Express, except for the addition of the tamping lever on the left side.

The pressure gauge is a standout feature for those who enjoy visual feedback on espresso extraction. This element makes the Impress model appealing to those who appreciate the charm of traditional espresso machines while still benefiting from some modern conveniences.

Barista Pro: A More Streamlined, Modern Look

The Barista Pro takes a more modern approach to design, replacing the analog gauge with an LCD screen. This sleek digital interface gives it a more futuristic and high-tech look, appealing to users who prefer a more minimalist, digital aesthetic. The buttons are fewer, and the interface is cleaner, making the machine feel more advanced while still maintaining ease of use.

If you prefer a classic, hands-on feel, the Impress model will likely appeal to you more. If you like a modern, high-tech experience, the Pro will be the better fit.

Size & Footprint: How Much Space Do They Take Up?

One of the biggest concerns for home espresso enthusiasts is how much counter space an espresso machine will occupy. Fortunately, both the Barista Express Impress and Barista Pro are designed to fit well in home kitchens without being overly bulky.

FeatureBarista Express ImpressBarista Pro
Dimensions (W x D x H)33 cm x 38 cm x 41 cm35.4 cm x 41 cm x 40.6 cm
Weight~12.9 kg (28.4 lbs)~9.1 kg (20.1 lbs)

Although they have similar footprints, the Impress model is slightly bulkier due to the tamping system on the left side. The Barista Pro is slightly lighter, which may be a factor if you plan to move it around frequently.

If counter space is limited, you’ll want to carefully measure your available space before purchasing. However, neither machine is significantly larger than the other, and both will fit comfortably in most kitchens.

Material Quality & Durability

Breville machines are known for their high-quality construction, and both the Impress and Pro models maintain this reputation.

Barista Express Impress: Sturdy and Reliable

The Impress model is built with a combination of brushed stainless steel and plastic components. The portafilter, tamping lever, and drip tray are all solidly constructed, giving the machine a premium feel. The buttons are tactile and well-placed, ensuring a satisfying user experience.

One notable aspect of the Impress model is the tamping mechanism, which is well-built and designed to last. However, because this is a mechanical part that experiences repeated use, there is a slight concern over long-term durability compared to manual tamping. While Breville machines are generally well-engineered, mechanical parts can develop wear and tear over time.

Barista Pro: Sleek and Robust

The Pro features a similar stainless steel body, but its buttons and LCD screen add a more modern touch. The portafilter, steam wand, and grinder components are all built with high-quality materials, ensuring long-term reliability.

A significant improvement in the Barista Pro is its upgraded drip tray and water tank design, which feel slightly more refined and easier to maintain. Because the machine doesn’t include an assisted tamping system, there’s less concern over potential wear and tear from moving parts.

Both machines are well-built, but if you’re concerned about mechanical durability, the Pro’s simpler design might be more reassuring

Control Layout & User Experience

A well-designed espresso machine should be easy to operate, with intuitive controls that allow users to make adjustments effortlessly.

Barista Express Impress: A More Traditional Interface

  • Analog pressure gauge provides real-time feedback on extraction.
  • Physical buttons for shot control and grinding offer a classic feel.
  • Tamping lever simplifies puck preparation but adds an extra step to the process.

One of the biggest advantages of the Impress model is that it automates dosing and tamping, which reduces the need for precise manual input. This makes it a fantastic option for beginners who want to get café-quality results without the trial-and-error process of manual tamping.

Barista Pro: A Modern Digital Interface

  • LCD screen with real-time information makes adjustments easier.
  • Streamlined button layout reduces clutter and enhances the overall look.
  • No assisted tamping, meaning you have complete manual control over puck preparation.

The Barista Pro’s digital display is a major selling point, providing information on grind size, shot time, and temperature settings. This allows for greater precision and control, making it an excellent choice for users who enjoy experimenting with different espresso variables.

If you prefer a more traditional espresso-making experience, the Impress model will feel more familiar. If you like modern, tech-driven interfaces, the Pro is the better choice.

Ergonomics & Workflow Efficiency

Espresso-making should be an enjoyable process, and how a machine is designed affects overall workflow.

Barista Express Impress: A More Guided Workflow

The assisted tamping system makes workflow slightly more structured. The process generally looks like this:

  1. Grind the coffee into the portafilter.
  2. Pull the tamping lever to apply pressure.
  3. Lock in the portafilter and pull your shot.

This system reduces mess and improves consistency but may feel restrictive for users who prefer to tweak their process manually.

Barista Pro: Faster and More Flexible Workflow

The ThermoJet heating system heats up in 3 seconds, allowing for much faster brewing. Additionally, because you tamp manually, you have more flexibility in adjusting your workflow based on your preferences.

For users who want a fast, efficient experience with more control, the Barista Pro is the better option.

Final Verdict on Design & Build Quality

  • Choose the Barista Express Impress if: You prefer a more classic espresso machine aesthetic, a traditional pressure gauge, and an assisted tamping system to simplify the process.
  • Choose the Barista Pro if: You want a sleek, modern design, a digital LCD interface, and a faster workflow with more manual control.

Both machines offer fantastic build quality and well-thought-out designs, but your choice will depend on whether you prefer a guided, consistent experience (Impress) or a faster, more customizable experience (Pro).

Ease of Use

When choosing a home espresso machine, ease of use is a crucial factor, especially if you’re a beginner or someone who values convenience in your daily coffee routine. Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro are designed to provide a semi-automatic espresso experience, but they differ significantly in terms of how much assistance they provide and how much control they require from the user.

This section will cover:

  • Getting started with each machine
  • Grinder operation and dosing consistency
  • Tamping process
  • Espresso extraction and shot control
  • Steam wand operation and milk frothing
  • Cleaning and maintenance ease

By the end of this section, you should have a clear understanding of which machine best suits your experience level and preference for control versus convenience.

Getting Started: Initial Setup and Learning Curve

Barista Express Impress: Designed for Beginners

If you’re new to making espresso at home, the Barista Express Impress is the more forgiving machine. It’s designed to take much of the guesswork out of dialing in your espresso, thanks to its Impress Puck System, which automates dosing and tamping.

The first time you use the Impress, the machine walks you through the setup process. The pre-programmed settings help guide you toward an optimal grind size and dose for your espresso. Once you load coffee beans and select a grind setting, the machine will automatically determine the correct amount of grounds needed for a proper shot and then guide you through tamping using the lever-assisted tamping system.

Overall, if you’ve never pulled a shot before, the Impress model provides a gentle learning curve by automating some of the most error-prone parts of the process.

Barista Pro: More Hands-On, Better for Experienced Users

The Barista Pro, on the other hand, is more of a traditional semi-automatic machine, meaning you have full control over grind size, dosing, and tamping. There is no assisted tamping, so you must tamp manually.

Getting started with the Pro requires more trial and error to find the right grind size and dose for your coffee beans. While the LCD screen provides helpful feedback on grind settings and shot timing, the machine itself does not adjust these parameters for you.

If you’re comfortable making adjustments or if you enjoy experimenting with different grind sizes and tamping pressures, the Pro is a fantastic choice. However, for complete beginners, the steeper learning curve might be intimidating at first.

Winner for beginners: Barista Express Impress
Winner for control and customization: Barista Pro

Grinder Operation and Dosing Consistency

Both machines come with a built-in conical burr grinder, which is an excellent feature because it eliminates the need for a separate grinder. However, there are key differences in how the grinders operate.

FeatureBarista Express ImpressBarista Pro
Number of Grind Settings25 grind settings30 grind settings
Grind Timer ControlAutomatic dosingManual control
Grind ConsistencyConsistent with auto-adjusting dosingMore precision, requires manual adjustment

Barista Express Impress: Automatic Dosing & Consistency

The Impress model automatically calculates the correct amount of coffee grounds based on the previous shot you pulled. This means you don’t have to worry about over- or under-dosing your portafilter.

For beginners, this is a huge advantage because one of the most common issues when making espresso is getting the correct amount of coffee in the portafilter. The Impress system adjusts the dose incrementally until it reaches the right amount, making it a set-and-forget feature.

Barista Pro: More Manual Control

The Pro gives you full control over the grinding process, allowing you to manually adjust the dose based on the type of beans you’re using. This offers greater precision but also requires more hands-on knowledge.

The 30 grind settings allow for slightly finer adjustments compared to the 25 settings on the Impress model. While this might not matter much for casual users, those who like to experiment with different beans will appreciate the added flexibility.

Winner for ease of grinding: Barista Express Impress
Winner for fine-tuning: Barista Pro

Tamping Process: Assisted vs. Manual

One of the biggest differences between these two machines is the tamping process.

Barista Express Impress: Assisted Tamping (Easier)

The Impress Puck System is a game-changer for beginners. Instead of manually tamping, you simply pull the tamping lever on the left side of the machine. The system ensures consistent pressure and levels the coffee puck evenly every time.

Since tamping inconsistencies can lead to poor extractions, this system significantly reduces human error. If you’re new to espresso, this feature will help you get better-tasting shots right away.

Barista Pro: Manual Tamping (More Control)

The Pro requires traditional tamping, meaning you’ll need to use the included stainless steel tamper to press the coffee grounds into the portafilter.

While this provides more flexibility and precision, it also introduces more room for error. Uneven tamping can result in channelling, where water flows through certain areas of the puck faster than others, leading to inconsistent extraction.

If you enjoy mastering the craft of espresso-making, manual tamping is the way to go. However, if you want effortless consistency, the assisted tamping of the Impress model is the better choice.

Winner for beginners: Barista Express Impress
Winner for control and customization: Barista Pro

Espresso Extraction and Shot Control

Once the coffee is ground and tamped, the next step is pulling the shot. Both machines offer pre-programmed single and double-shot options, but they differ in how they handle extraction.

  • The Impress model provides a pressure gauge, giving you visual feedback on whether your shot is pulling correctly.
  • The Pro provides an LCD screen that displays extraction time, which is just as useful but requires you to understand what ideal shot timing looks like.

Since the Impress model automatically adjusts the dose over time, it helps beginners get consistently good shots faster. Meanwhile, the Pro requires you to fine-tune your technique manually, which can be more rewarding but also more frustrating if you’re not experienced.

Winner for set-and-forget convenience: Barista Express Impress
Winner for manual refinement: Barista Pro

Steam Wand Operation and Milk Frothing

Both machines feature powerful steam wands, but the Pro’s is significantly more efficient.

  • The Impress steam wand is manual and takes some time to heat up. It’s suitable for beginners but takes longer to froth milk.
  • The Pro steam wand heats up almost instantly, thanks to the ThermoJet system. It is more powerful and produces better microfoam for latte art.

If you make a lot of milk-based drinks, the Pro is the clear winner in this category.

Final Verdict on Ease of Use

  • Choose the Barista Express Impress if: You’re a beginner or prefer automation for dosing and tamping.
  • Choose the Barista Pro if: You enjoy hands-on control and don’t mind manually dialing in your espresso.

For those who want a user-friendly, foolproof experience, the Barista Express Impress is the better choice. However, if you’re looking for greater customization and faster operation, the Barista Pro is superior.

Grinding Performance

A high-quality grinder is essential for making great espresso. The consistency and precision of the grind directly impact the flavor, extraction quality, and overall espresso experience. Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro come with a built-in conical burr grinder, which eliminates the need for a separate grinder and ensures you get fresh ground coffee for every shot.

While both machines have similar grinders, there are differences in grind settings, dosing accuracy, ease of use, and overall performance that might influence your buying decision. Let’s explore these factors in detail.

Built-In Grinder: Similarities and Differences

Both machines feature an integrated stainless steel conical burr grinder, a significant convenience for home baristas. Having a grinder built into the machine ensures freshly ground coffee on demand and helps maintain an organized, compact setup without needing additional equipment.

However, there are some notable differences between the two models:

FeatureBarista Express ImpressBarista Pro
Grind Settings25 grind settings30 grind settings
Grind Timer ControlAuto-dosing with adjustmentsManual grind control
Dosing ConsistencyAssisted, auto-adjustingManual, more precise
Noise LevelModerateQuieter than Impress
Speed of GrindingSlowerFaster

The Barista Pro has a slight edge due to its higher number of grind settings (30 vs. 25), which allows for finer adjustments. This means greater flexibility in dialing in your espresso, which is especially important if you frequently switch between different types of beans.

Grind Consistency and Precision

Barista Express Impress: Beginner-Friendly and Automated

The Barista Express Impress is designed to help beginners achieve consistent results without needing extensive knowledge of grind size and dosing. The automatic dosing system uses an intelligent algorithm to adjust the dose based on previous shots, reducing the chance of getting too much or too little coffee.

  • Impress Puck System: One of the biggest advantages of the Impress model is its ability to fine-tune the dose automatically over time. If your first shot is slightly under-dosed, the machine remembers and adjusts the dose incrementally for the next shot.
  • Pre-set grind timer: While you can manually adjust grind size, the machine automatically grinds the right amount of coffee based on previous extractions.
  • Consistency: Since tamping is assisted, the Impress model ensures more uniform extractions, making it easier to get a well-balanced shot.

The downside of this system is that it offers less manual control. If you want to adjust your dose precisely or experiment with different grind sizes, the Impress model may feel a bit restrictive.

Barista Pro: More Control and Finer Adjustments

The Barista Pro, on the other hand, offers manual control over the grind dose, allowing users to tweak every aspect of their shot. This makes it better suited for intermediate or advanced users who enjoy experimenting with different coffee beans and dialing in their espresso manually.

  • 30 grind settings: The Pro has more granularity in grind size adjustment, making it easier to fine-tune your shot.
  • Manual dosing control: You decide how much coffee to grind, which is great for those who like to tweak their recipes.
  • Greater precision: While this gives you more flexibility, it also means you need to know what you’re doing—there’s no automatic adjustment if your dose is off.

For users who are comfortable fine-tuning their espresso, the Pro’s extra grind settings and manual dosing offer a higher level of precision.

Speed and Noise Level

Another major difference between the two grinders is speed and noise level.

Barista Express Impress: Slower, Moderate Noise

The grinder in the Impress model is slightly slower compared to the Pro. While this isn’t a huge issue, it means it takes a few extra seconds to grind a dose. Additionally, the Impress model is a bit noisier, which may be a factor if you make coffee early in the morning and want a quieter experience.

Barista Pro: Faster and Quieter

The Pro’s grinder is faster and significantly quieter. This can make a difference if you’re making multiple drinks back-to-back or if you’re someone who values a quick and quiet morning routine.

If speed and noise level are important considerations, the Barista Pro has a clear advantage.

Workflow and Ease of Use

Barista Express Impress: Simplified Process

The Impress model is designed for ease of use, making it an excellent choice for those who don’t want to fuss over grind settings and dosing adjustments.

  • Automatic dosing removes guesswork
  • Assisted tamping ensures a level, consistent puck
  • Grind settings are adjustable, but the machine helps guide you toward the right choice

If you want a plug-and-play experience where the machine does most of the work for you, the Impress is a fantastic option.

Barista Pro: More Hands-On Control

The Pro is geared toward users who want to be more involved in their espresso-making process.

  • You must adjust the grind size manually based on the type of beans and extraction time.
  • You have full control over dosing, which means you must measure and tamp manually.
  • The LCD screen helps with guidance, but you’ll still need to fine-tune your technique.

For those who enjoy learning the nuances of espresso-making, the Pro provides a more engaging, customizable workflow.

Which Machine is Better for Grinding Performance?

Choose the Barista Express Impress if:

✔ You want automation—the machine helps adjust dosing automatically.
✔ You’re a beginner and need a guided experience.
✔ You prefer a consistent grind and puck preparation without needing to manually adjust every shot.

Choose the Barista Pro if:

✔ You want more precise control over grind size and dosing.
✔ You like to experiment with different coffee beans and need finer adjustments.
✔ You value a faster, quieter grinder and a more customizable workflow.

Final Verdict:

  • If you’re looking for simplicity and consistency, the Barista Express Impress is the winner.
  • If you want more control and better fine-tuning capabilities, the Barista Pro comes out ahead.

Both machines provide great grinding performance, but the right choice depends on how much manual control you want over your espresso-making process.

Espresso Quality & Extraction

When it comes to making a great espresso, quality and extraction consistency are the most important factors to consider. A good espresso machine should be able to deliver rich, balanced, and flavorful shots with proper crema, while also allowing for fine-tuning to match different beans and brewing styles.

Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro are capable of producing excellent espresso, but they take different approaches to achieving optimal results. In this section, we’ll explore their extraction process, shot consistency, pre-infusion technology, heating systems, and overall espresso quality to help you determine which machine is best for your needs.

Espresso Extraction Process

Espresso extraction is a delicate balance of grind size, dosing, tamping, water temperature, and pressure. Both machines follow the same basic process:

  1. Grinding the coffee beans with a built-in conical burr grinder.
  2. Dosing and tamping the grounds into the portafilter.
  3. Pre-infusing the coffee puck with low-pressure water to bloom the grounds.
  4. Applying high-pressure water (9 bars) to extract the espresso shot.

While both machines share this process, the way they execute each step differs slightly, leading to notable variations in shot quality and consistency.

Heating System and Temperature Stability

One of the most critical aspects of espresso quality is temperature stability. If water temperature fluctuates too much during extraction, the espresso can taste either under-extracted (sour, weak, watery) or over-extracted (bitter, harsh, burnt).

Barista Express Impress: Thermocoil Heating System

The Barista Express Impress uses a thermocoil heating system, which takes about 30 seconds to fully heat up. While this is much faster than traditional boilers, temperature fluctuations can occur because the heating system isn’t as advanced as Breville’s newer ThermoJet technology.

  • Preheating takes longer than the Barista Pro (30 seconds vs. 3 seconds).
  • Recovery time between shots is slightly slower.
  • Temperature stability is good but not as precise as the Pro.

The thermocoil system is still capable of producing high-quality espresso, but users might notice small inconsistencies in extraction temperature, especially when pulling multiple shots back to back.

Barista Pro: ThermoJet Heating System

The Barista Pro features Breville’s ThermoJet heating system, which is significantly faster and more consistent than the Impress model.

  • Heats up in just 3 seconds, making it much quicker to start brewing.
  • More precise temperature control, leading to better extraction consistency.
  • Faster recovery time between shots, ideal for making multiple drinks quickly.

Because the Pro maintains a more stable temperature throughout extraction, it ensures more consistent shot quality, particularly if you’re brewing multiple espressos in a row.

Winner for temperature stability: Barista Pro

Pre-Infusion Technology

Pre-infusion is a crucial step in espresso extraction. It gently wets the coffee grounds with low-pressure water before applying full pressure. This helps even out extraction, preventing channeling and leading to a more balanced shot.

Both machines feature Breville’s low-pressure pre-infusion, which is designed to enhance flavor clarity and ensure an even extraction. However, the Barista Pro’s faster and more stable heating system makes its pre-infusion process slightly more effective.

  • The Impress model applies pre-infusion at low pressure but may suffer slightly from temperature inconsistencies if shots are pulled too quickly in succession.
  • The Pro model applies pre-infusion more evenly and consistently, thanks to its more advanced temperature control.

For most users, the difference in pre-infusion performance will be minor, but if you’re very particular about espresso quality, the Pro has a slight advantage.

Winner for pre-infusion consistency: Barista Pro

Shot Quality and Crema

Espresso quality is ultimately judged by taste, aroma, body, and crema. Let’s compare how each machine performs in these areas.

Barista Express Impress: Beginner-Friendly Shot Quality

Thanks to the Impress Puck System, which assists with dosing and tamping, the Barista Express Impress is fantastic for beginners who want to achieve consistent, café-quality shots without much trial and error.

  • Produces rich, full-bodied espresso with good crema.
  • The assisted tamping system reduces errors, ensuring even extractions.
  • Slightly more prone to temperature fluctuations, which may affect flavor clarity in some cases.

For those who don’t want to spend time fine-tuning their shots, the Barista Express Impress delivers reliable espresso quality with minimal effort.

Barista Pro: More Control, Better Crema

Because the Pro offers more grind settings, manual tamping, and better temperature stability, it allows users to dial in their espresso more precisely, resulting in:

  • More consistent crema, thanks to better temperature control.
  • Greater depth of flavor, particularly for those who experiment with different beans.
  • More control over shot variables, making it ideal for advanced users who want to fine-tune every aspect of their espresso.

For users who enjoy experimenting with different beans and fine-tuning their espresso shots, the Barista Pro delivers superior results.

Winner for shot quality and crema: Barista Pro

Shot Customization & User Control

If you enjoy tweaking your espresso variables, the Barista Pro offers more control over the process.

  • Barista Express Impress: Limited shot customization due to automated tamping and dosing adjustments.
  • Barista Pro: More flexibility in adjusting grind size, dose, and tamp pressure, allowing for a truly customized espresso experience.

While the Impress model simplifies the process, the Pro gives users complete control, which is ideal for those who want to refine their technique over time.

Winner for shot customization: Barista Pro

Workflow & Convenience

Barista Express Impress: Simplified, Guided Workflow

  • Best for users who want high-quality espresso with minimal effort.
  • Automated tamping and dosing adjustments make it easier to get a consistent shot.
  • Pressure gauge provides visual feedback for shot optimization.

Barista Pro: Faster, More Efficient Workflow

  • 3-second heat-up time means you can brew shots almost instantly.
  • More precise grind settings and manual tamping allow for better refinement.
  • LCD screen provides clear guidance on shot timing, making it easier to make adjustments.

If you want a quick and efficient espresso-making experience, the Barista Pro is the better choice.

Winner for workflow efficiency: Barista Pro

Final Verdict: Which Machine Produces the Best Espresso?

CategoryBarista Express ImpressBarista Pro
Temperature StabilityGood, but slightly inconsistentExcellent, very stable
Pre-InfusionWorks well, but less consistentMore precise and even
Shot ConsistencyVery good, easy for beginnersMore control, better for advanced users
Crema QualityGood, but slightly less refinedExcellent, rich crema
CustomizationLimited (automated adjustments)Full manual control
Workflow SpeedSlower due to longer heat-upFaster (3-second heat-up)

Choose the Barista Express Impress if:

✔ You want a beginner-friendly machine that helps guide you toward better espresso.
✔ You prefer assisted tamping for more consistent extractions.
✔ You don’t mind slightly longer heat-up times.

Choose the Barista Pro if:

✔ You want faster heat-up and better temperature stability.
✔ You like manual control over tamping, grind size, and extraction.
✔ You want better crema, flavor clarity, and the ability to fine-tune your shots.

For ease of use and consistency, the Impress is fantastic. But if you want better espresso quality, crema, and more control, the Barista Pro is the clear winner.

Milk Frothing Performance

For those who love milk-based espresso drinks like lattes, cappuccinos, and flat whites, milk frothing performance is a crucial factor when choosing an espresso machine. A high-quality steam wand should be powerful, efficient, and capable of creating microfoam for smooth, velvety milk texture. Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro come equipped with a professional-style steam wand, but there are key differences in power, speed, ease of use, and foam quality that can influence your decision.

Steam Wand Power and Performance

One of the biggest differences between these two machines is the power and efficiency of the steam wand.

Barista Express Impress: Standard Thermocoil Steam Wand

The Barista Express Impress features a manual steam wand that is capable of creating microfoam, but it is less powerful compared to the Pro.

  • Takes longer to heat up (due to the thermocoil heating system).
  • Produces decent microfoam, but requires more technique and patience.
  • Less powerful steam pressure, meaning it takes longer to froth milk compared to commercial machines.

For beginners, this steam wand is more forgiving because it gives you more time to control the frothing process. However, for those who want to make multiple milk-based drinks quickly, it can feel slow and less efficient.

Barista Pro: Powerful ThermoJet Steam Wand

The Barista Pro’s steam wand is significantly more powerful thanks to its ThermoJet heating system, which allows for near-instant steam readiness.

  • Steam is available almost immediately (within a few seconds).
  • Stronger steam pressure, meaning faster milk frothing times.
  • Easier to create professional-grade microfoam for latte art.

This makes the Pro better suited for those who frequently make milk-based drinks, as it allows for faster steaming and better texturing.

Winner for steam power: Barista Pro

Speed and Efficiency

Speed is important when it comes to milk frothing, especially if you make multiple drinks in a row or if you want to save time in the morning.

  • The Barista Express Impress takes longer to produce steam, and frothing milk can take around 45-60 seconds.
  • The Barista Pro heats up almost instantly and can froth milk in 20-30 seconds, nearly cutting the time in half.

If you often make back-to-back lattes or cappuccinos, the Barista Pro is the better choice due to its faster recovery time and more powerful steam wand.

Winner for speed: Barista Pro

Ease of Use

Barista Express Impress: Easier for Beginners

Since the steam wand is less powerful, beginners may find it easier to control. It gives you more time to adjust your milk frothing technique, making it less intimidating for new users. However, because the pressure is lower, it requires more skill and effort to get fine microfoam.

Barista Pro: Faster, But Requires More Skill

The Barista Pro’s wand is more powerful, meaning less time to adjust your technique. If you don’t angle the steam wand correctly, you may end up with large bubbles instead of silky foam. That said, once you get used to it, the Pro’s steam wand allows for more precise milk texturing, which is great for latte art enthusiasts.

Winner for ease of learning: Barista Express Impress
Winner for advanced control: Barista Pro

Milk Texture and Microfoam Quality

For lattes and cappuccinos, achieving silky microfoam is key.

  • The Barista Express Impress produces good microfoam, but it requires more effort and patience.
  • The Barista Pro produces superior microfoam, thanks to its higher steam power and faster heating.

If you enjoy latte art, the Barista Pro is the better option because it creates finer, more consistent foam.

Winner for milk texture: Barista Pro

Final Verdict: Which Machine is Better for Milk Frothing?

CategoryBarista Express ImpressBarista Pro
Steam PowerModerateStrong, commercial-like
SpeedSlowerFast, near-instant steam
Ease of UseEasier for beginnersRequires more skill but more control
Milk TextureGood, but less refinedExcellent, professional-grade
Best ForCasual users, beginnersFrequent milk drinkers, latte art lovers

Choose the Barista Express Impress if:

✔ You’re a beginner and need a less powerful, more forgiving steam wand.
✔ You don’t mind longer frothing times.
✔ You only make occasional milk-based drinks and prefer a slower learning curve.

Choose the Barista Pro if:

✔ You want faster, more powerful steaming for better microfoam.
✔ You make a lot of milk-based drinks and need efficiency.
✔ You love latte art and want barista-quality milk texture.

Overall Winner: Barista Pro for its faster, more powerful steam wand and superior milk texturing capabilities. However, if you’re a beginner who prioritizes ease of learning, the Barista Express Impress is a solid choice.

Cleaning & Maintenance

Proper cleaning and maintenance are essential for keeping your espresso machine in top shape, ensuring great-tasting coffee, and prolonging the life of the machine. Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro require regular upkeep, but there are differences in ease of cleaning, automated features, and maintenance reminders that might impact your choice.

This section will cover:

  • Daily cleaning routines
  • Backflushing and deep cleaning
  • Descaling requirements
  • Steam wand maintenance
  • Drip tray and water reservoir upkeep
  • Long-term durability considerations

By the end of this section, you’ll know which machine offers a more convenient cleaning experience and which one requires more manual effort.

Daily Cleaning Routines

Barista Express Impress: Automated Dosing Reduces Mess

One of the advantages of the Impress model is its assisted tamping system, which reduces mess when preparing coffee. The Impress Puck System ensures that the coffee grounds are properly compressed, preventing excess coffee from spilling onto the drip tray or counter.

  • Portafilter Cleaning: After pulling a shot, the coffee puck is usually dry and easy to remove.
  • Grinder Cleaning: Since the Impress system automatically doses and tamps, there’s less coffee ground spillage around the portafilter area.
  • Steam Wand: Requires wiping immediately after use to prevent milk from drying and clogging the nozzle.

Since the grind dosing and tamping process are automated, the Barista Express Impress generally requires less cleanup after each use.

Barista Pro: More Manual Cleanup Required

The Barista Pro, on the other hand, is a fully manual machine, meaning you’ll have to be more involved in keeping it clean.

  • Portafilter Cleaning: If you don’t distribute and tamp the coffee properly, the puck may be wetter and messier to remove.
  • Grinder Cleaning: Since dosing is manual, there’s a higher chance of coffee grounds spilling onto the drip tray and countertop.
  • Steam Wand: Just like with the Impress, it’s crucial to purge and wipe the wand immediately after frothing milk to avoid blockages.

If you prefer a cleaner, more streamlined espresso-making process, the Impress model wins because it reduces excess coffee grounds mess.

Winner for daily cleaning ease: Barista Express Impress

Backflushing and Group Head Cleaning

Both machines require regular backflushing to clean the group head and remove coffee oils that can build up over time.

  • Backflushing should be done weekly if you use the machine daily.
  • Breville provides cleaning tablets that help break down coffee residue.

Barista Express Impress: Assisted Cleaning Reminders

The Impress model comes with cleaning cycle alerts, prompting users to run the automated cleaning cycle when necessary. The process is straightforward and involves inserting a cleaning disc into the portafilter, adding a cleaning tablet, and running the cycle.

Barista Pro: Manual Backflushing Required

The Barista Pro also requires backflushing, but since it’s a more manual machine, users need to remember to do it regularly. The LCD screen provides cleaning reminders, but the process is still user-initiated.

Both machines require the same cleaning frequency, but the Impress model is slightly more user-friendly since it automatically adjusts settings to ensure optimal performance.

Winner for backflushing convenience: Barista Express Impress

Descaling and Water System Maintenance

Descaling is another essential part of maintaining an espresso machine. Over time, mineral deposits from water can build up inside the internal components, affecting performance.

  • Breville recommends descaling every 2-3 months, depending on water hardness.
  • Using a water filter reduces the need for frequent descaling.

Barista Express Impress: Simplified Descaling Alerts

The Impress model has a built-in descaling alert, which notifies users when it’s time to run the descaling cycle.

Barista Pro: More Manual Descaling Process

The Barista Pro also requires descaling but does not automatically adjust settings based on usage. Instead, the LCD screen provides a notification, and the process must be manually started by the user.

Since both machines require descaling, but the Impress model has more intuitive alerts, it has a slight edge in this category.

Winner for descaling ease: Barista Express Impress

Steam Wand Maintenance

The steam wand requires immediate cleaning after every use to prevent milk from clogging the nozzle.

Barista Express Impress: Standard Steam Wand Cleaning

The steam wand on the Impress model is effective but slightly less powerful than the Pro. Since it produces less steam pressure, milk tends to stick more easily to the wand, requiring a thorough wipe after each use.

Barista Pro: More Steam Power, But More Maintenance

The Pro’s steam wand is more powerful, meaning it froths milk faster. However, this also means that milk dries more quickly on the wand, requiring immediate wiping and purging.

Both machines require the same level of steam wand maintenance, but since the Pro’s wand is more powerful, it’s slightly more prone to blockages if not cleaned immediately.

Winner: Tie – Both require immediate cleaning

Drip Tray & Water Reservoir Maintenance

Both machines have a removable drip tray and water reservoir, which should be cleaned regularly to prevent mold and mineral buildup.

Drip Tray Cleaning

  • The Impress model has a larger drip tray, which means it requires less frequent emptying.
  • The Pro has a smaller drip tray, so if you use the machine frequently, you’ll need to empty it more often.

Water Reservoir Cleaning

Both machines feature a 2L (67oz) removable water reservoir, making cleaning relatively simple. If you use a water filter, you can reduce scale buildup and extend the time between deep cleans.

Since the Impress model has a larger drip tray, it requires slightly less frequent emptying, giving it a minor advantage.

Winner: Barista Express Impress (due to larger drip tray)

Long-Term Maintenance & Durability

Barista Express Impress: More Mechanical Components

The Impress model has extra mechanical parts, such as the assisted tamping system, which could potentially wear down over time. While Breville machines are generally durable, the more moving parts a machine has, the higher the risk of something breaking.

Barista Pro: Fewer Moving Parts, More Manual Control

The Pro has fewer mechanical components, meaning there are fewer parts that can fail. This could make it slightly more durable in the long run, especially for users who take good care of their machine.

If long-term reliability and fewer mechanical issues are priorities, the Barista Pro is a better choice.

Winner for long-term durability: Barista Pro

Final Verdict: Which Machine is Easier to Clean & Maintain?

CategoryBarista Express ImpressBarista Pro
Daily CleaningEasier, less messRequires more manual cleanup
BackflushingAutomated remindersManual process
DescalingAutomatic alertsManual reminders
Steam WandRequires wiping after useRequires immediate purging
Drip Tray SizeLarger (less frequent emptying)Smaller (requires more frequent emptying)
DurabilityMore moving parts (higher risk)Fewer moving parts (longer lifespan)

Choose the Barista Express Impress if:

✔ You want automated cleaning reminders.
✔ You prefer a less messy espresso workflow.
✔ You don’t mind occasional mechanical maintenance.

Choose the Barista Pro if:

✔ You prefer long-term durability with fewer mechanical parts.
✔ You don’t mind manual cleaning and maintenance.
✔ You want more control over the cleaning process.

Overall Winner: Barista Express Impress for ease of maintenance, but Barista Pro for long-term durability.

Price & Value

When investing in a home espresso machine, price is an important factor, but value goes beyond just the upfront cost. The right machine should provide long-term benefits in terms of quality, features, and overall user experience. Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro fall into the mid-range price category, making them excellent choices for home baristas who want a balance of affordability and professional performance.

In this section, we’ll compare:

  • Upfront cost
  • Features vs. price
  • Long-term value

Upfront Cost: Which Machine Costs More?

While prices can fluctuate based on retailer promotions and sales, here are the approximate costs:

MachinePrice Range (USD)
Breville Barista Express Impress$799 – $899
Breville Barista Pro$849 – $999

Barista Express Impress: More Affordable with Assisted Features

  • The Impress model is generally less expensive than the Barista Pro.
  • It includes automated tamping, which is a premium feature that adds value for beginners.
  • Despite its slightly lower price, it provides high-quality espresso with less manual effort.

Barista Pro: Higher Price, More Advanced Features

  • The Pro is usually $50-$100 more expensive than the Impress.
  • The faster heating system, better steam wand, and digital LCD interface justify the price difference.
  • The manual tamping process makes it better suited for experienced users who prefer more control.

If you’re on a tighter budget and want more automation, the Impress model offers better value. However, if you’re willing to pay more for speed and customization, the Pro is worth the extra investment.

Features vs. Price: Which Machine Offers Better Value?

Value is determined by how much functionality and convenience you get for the price.

FeatureBarista Express ImpressBarista Pro
Built-in Grinder✅ Yes✅ Yes
Tamping System✅ Assisted❌ Manual
Heating System🔥 Thermocoil⚡ ThermoJet (3s heat-up)
Steam Wand⚡ Good⚡⚡ Excellent (faster & stronger)
LCD Screen❌ No (analog pressure gauge)✅ Yes (digital control)
Ease of Use✅ Easier for beginners❌ Requires more skill
Shot Control✅ More automated✅ More customizable
  • For beginners: The Barista Express Impress is a better value because it includes automated tamping and dosing adjustments without extra cost.
  • For enthusiasts: The Barista Pro is worth the higher price due to its faster heat-up time, better steam wand, and more grind settings.

Long-Term Value: Which Machine Is a Better Investment?

  • The Barista Express Impress requires less manual skill but has more mechanical parts, which might lead to higher maintenance costs in the long run.
  • The Barista Pro has fewer moving parts, meaning it may last longer with proper maintenance.

If you plan to upgrade your skills over time, the Barista Pro offers better long-term value. However, if you want a hassle-free espresso experience without additional accessories, the Impress model is the better value for money.

Overall Winner: Barista Express Impress for affordability, Barista Pro for long-term investment.

Final Verdict: Which Machine Should You Choose?

Both the Breville Barista Express Impress and Breville Barista Pro are excellent home espresso machines, but they cater to different types of users. The best choice depends on your experience level, priorities, and how much control you want over the espresso-making process.

Choose the Breville Barista Express Impress if:

You’re a beginner and want a more forgiving machine that simplifies the process.
You prefer automation, with features like assisted tamping and automatic dosing adjustments.
You value affordability, as the Impress is generally less expensive than the Pro.
You don’t mind a slower workflow, since it has a longer heat-up time and less powerful steam wand.

Choose the Breville Barista Pro if:

You want more control over your espresso, including manual tamping and grind adjustments.
You value speed, as the ThermoJet heating system (3-second heat-up) makes it faster and more efficient.
You make a lot of milk-based drinks, since the Pro has a more powerful steam wand for better microfoam.
You want long-term durability, with fewer moving parts and a more customizable experience.

Overall Recommendation:

  • If you prioritize ease of use and consistency, go for the Barista Express Impress.
  • If you prefer more manual control and better performance, the Barista Pro is the better investment.

Both machines deliver fantastic espresso, but the right choice depends on how much control vs. convenience you want in your coffee-making experience.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top